This post is being cross-posted on jackslashjosh, my new cooperative blog with Josh Richard.

I love Google Wave. I really do. When I got my invite the other day, I squealed with delight (but in a really manly way). Since that time, I have created several Waves with folks for a variety of reasons, and the whole system has proven pretty effective and fairly efficient.
You’ll also notice that we have our own little wave going here at jackslashjosh. Just click on that top right-hand corner thing and – if you have Google Wave already – type us something.
That said, there are definitely a few really annoying things about Google Wave. Don’t misunderstand – I’m totally aware that it’s in “Beta”. Still, what would a Beta be if I couldn’t offer criticism?
Thus, I present to you…
Things that frustrate me about Google Wave:
1) Pinging is the most impolite form of communication imaginable. In concept, “pinging” someone is supposed to be kind of like sending them an Instant Message…except that, you know, it’s not.
For starters, it doesn’t work the same way as Instant Messaging. Pinging someone essentially just starts a new wave with them, which is odd, because instant messaging is a type of communication that is NOTHING LIKE A WAVE.
See, instant messaging is supposed to mimic actual conversation. This makes sense, because inpolite conversation people take turns. Sure, two people in a conversation might say something at the same time, but then they say “jinx!”, laugh it off, and move on.
But nooooo, “Pinging” doesn’t let you laugh it off. No, pinging makes you watch the other person type while you try to have a conversation. Thus, a conversation between two people quickly turns into a who-can-type-faster-so-you-get-out-what-you-want-to-say-first-oh-god-I-just-misspelled-that-let-me-fix-it-before-she-notices contest. It turns both parties into interrupter kings a la Rep. Joe Wilson, and I am NOT okay with that.
Also, pinging makes me incredibly self-conscious about my typing abilities, and that si nto colo, oGoleg.
2) Google Wave hates the rest of Google, and the rest of Google hates Google wave.
…And we all lose because of it. Let me explain: somewhere along the way, Google Wave decided that it wanted to be the new King of Communication. After coming to this new realization, the Google Wave folks ALSO decided that the best way to do this is by IGNORING every other form of digital communication.
First, they started by beating Instant Messaging into a hollow shell of its former self (see above).
Second, I can’t get email updates or have a notifier tell when a Google Wave is updated. This is stupid.
Don’t get me wrong, I understand the logic here: why should I have to go through two forms of communication when I can just go through one and check your Google Wave? Well, Mr. Inquisitive, I’ll tell you why:
I have an iPhone. Do you know why I love my iPhone? Believe it or not, it’s not because I have an application that lets me roll a creepy-noise-making imaginary monkey around suspended platforms of death (although that is awesome): it is, instead because my iPhone gets my email. Why is that cool? Because that means I can work/play/communicate with ANYONE no matter WHERE I am on earth. (before you say anything, places without 3G service do not, in fact, count as “earth”)
But guess what I can’t do with my iPhone? Oh, that’s right, I can’t access ANY form of Google Wave, so I can’t have ANY idea what’s going on in a Wave unless I’m sitting on my computer with it open in my browser.
So, you know, I COULD do work on the “super efficient” Google Wave and only be able to talk to my co-wavers when I’m sitting in front of a computer with a really good internet connection…
…Or I could just, you know, use email, and talk to anyone whenever I want.
Also, this “screw the world” approach to the rest of communication has right ticked some other people at Google off. The creator of Gmail, for instance, hasn’t even tried the dang thing.
3) The idea that Google Wave is a new, novel concept – it’s not. Don’t get me wrong – Google wave in its current incarnation is certainly a new thing for the masses, and it is definitely new to have all of these technologies shoved together into one package within a browser.
That said, there are some things that predate Google Wave by about 12 years – namely, Hotline. Granted, Hotline was a desktop application and did not have the in-browser gee-whizz effect that Google Wave does. Still, the little program had a host of great features:
- the ability to live-chat with a group of people, and watch what they type AS they type it.
- the ability to have host dozens of people per server (think “wave”) and allow them all to participate
- the ability to have someone send you a direct message outside of the group chat window (think “ping”)
- the to drag-and-drop files on a server and allow people to access those files all at once.
Sound familiar? It should: it’s a lot like the Google Wave list of features. Granted, Google Wave and Hotline still have a lot of differences, but I just want to point out that the amalgamation of these features into one program isn’t necessarily “new.”
4) Google Wave is based in Australia. As we all know, Australians do crazy, crazy things (I’m looking at you, Josh). I’m not saying that this will make Google Wave crazy…but it’s worth thinking about, and don’t blame me when a Croc eats your Wave.
So there you have it, folks. If you have any comments on the subject, feel free to let us know by clicking the Wave icon in the top-left corner of the blog….
…and then you can bask in the irony.